Immigration

Candidates’ rhetoric about immigration reform is like peeling an egg

Candidates’ rhetoric about immigration reform is like peeling an egg

LatinaLista — It doesn't matter which side is talking about immigration these days because, like an overboiled egg, there are too many cracks in what's being said to know if their ideas are fully cooked or not.

(Source: cbs.com)
For example, today, Senator John McCain, chose to speak about immigration before a "non-Hispanic" audience. That's a rarity since it's pretty much understood that it's a radioactive topic with most of his supporters. What made today so different was that he was in Scranton, PA and he wasn't talking about Hispanic undocumented immigrants but Irish.
Yet, in reading the following quote, one can't shake the notion that it was delivered along the same lines as his infamous "Hispanics are God's children too" ad.
"This nation is all the stronger -- this nation is stronger, this nation is stronger -- for the infusion of fresh blood and vitality that has come to this nation wave after wave: Irish, Italian, Poles, everybody who's come to this nation has enriched our nation, including our Hispanic citizenry. OK? That's what America's all about."
While McCain has made no secret that before he supports any type of immigration reform, the border has to be secured first, it's clearly not a priority issue with him. As one reporter noted, McCain won't talk about immigration "unless the subject is something of particular interest to his audience, or he is asked about it."
On the other hand, Obama has talked about reforming immigration and he even answered a questionnaire on the topic sent to his campaign - something the McCain campaign refused to do, let alone acknowledge.
In the past, Obama has said that he will address the topic of immigration reform in his first year of office. Yet in an interview aired on 60 Minutes over the weekend, Obama identified the two most pressing issues that he would work on immediately — the economy and the war in Iraq.
Two issues that definitely are of vital importance to the nation and which are, in and of themselves, as complex as the immigration issue. It's a safe bet that these two issues alone can occupy any new administration for a good while.
So where does that leave the issue of immigration?


If the current rhetoric is applied to fixing the immigration problem, then it's clear that both sides want to still address only the symptoms of illegal immigration, rather than looking at the core of the problem which is two-fold: undocumented immigrants are overcoming border security measures to arrive daily because work still exists and/or undocumented immigrants are reuniting with family members.
It's one thing to force all businesses to run their hires through E-Verify and penalize them for hiring undocumented workers but it's another to purposely keep parents separated from children or children separated from their parents because of a difference in legal status between the two.
The trouble with the current rhetoric on immigration reform is that everyone thinks that there are no more solutions for the issue or even a new way to address it. Just like most everyone thinks there's only one way to peel an egg.
There's always a new way to think about something — there just has to be the will to create a new vision.

Immigration

More in Immigration

JLBPHOTO_Immigration_013

HBO’s Vice takes in-depth look at Alabama after harsh 2011 anti-immigrant bill

Latina ListaApril 24, 2015
imrs

Breaking News: White House says today’s court ruling doesn’t affect current DACA program

Latina ListaFebruary 17, 2015
Eloisa_Mata,_left,_and_Maria_Calixto,_right,_work_on_DACA_cases

New bilingual online platform helps DREAMers and other immigrants navigate, complete and file immigration paperwork

Latina ListaFebruary 10, 2015
2014_US_immigration_presser_plus_0

Deporting parents of US citizen children provides window to shaky national future

Latina ListaJanuary 12, 2015
Immigrants Rally To Thank Obama

Separate polls show Obama’s base approve his Executive Action, leaving critics red

Latina ListaNovember 24, 2014
2014-06-27-ImmigrationreformrallyinLosAngeles_5_1

New Pew report shows decline of undocumented immigration in 14 states, while 7 saw a rise

Latina ListaNovember 18, 2014
facingrace-BALTIMORE-thumb-640xauto-5126

DREAMer activist on path to lead the way in overcoming injustice

Latina ListaNovember 17, 2014
Undocumented-Illegal-Immigrant

New Pew study finds undocumented population no longer growing, but settling in as Americans

Latina ListaSeptember 3, 2014
latinosscotussb10170-e1340588300634

Part 1: The political reality of immigration reform

Latina ListaAugust 29, 2014