Guest Voz

Guest Voz: Rep. Luis Gutierrez tells Puerto Rico legislature it’s his duty to speak out

Guest Voz: Rep. Luis Gutierrez tells Puerto Rico legislature it’s his duty to speak out

LatinaLista -- On Feb. 16, 2011, Illinois Rep. Luis Gutierrez delivered remarks on the floor of the House of Representatives about the civil unrest happening in Puerto Rico.


Rep. Gutierrez wanted to alert his colleagues, and the rest of the nation, to the civil rights and human rights violations happening on the island by the local police towards student protesters. He outlined how the island's government and law enforcement are continuously violating the First Amendment rights of Puerto Ricans by intimidating people with beatings or jailing them for speaking out or protesting. In fact, according to Gutierrez, the Puerto Rican legislature has dismantled the bar association because it took a stand opposing the government.

When Rep. Gutierrez delivered his remarks, he knew airing Puerto Rico's dirty laundry wouldn't make some people back on the island very happy. Yet, even he could not have expected the backlash that has been targeted at him from Puerto Rico's legislature or the Puerto Rican representative in Congress.

So, Rep. Gutierrez returned to the House floor to answer his critics, and in the process, challenges all Americans to take notice on this nation's closest colony.


MARCH 2, 2011

Two weeks ago I spoke about a serious problem in Puerto Rico.

The problem is a systemic effort by the ruling party to deny the right of the people to speak freely, to criticize their government openly, and to make their voices heard.

I talked about student protests that had been met with violent resistance by Puerto Rican police. I talked about closed meetings of the legislature, and about efforts to silence the local Bar Association.

I was not the first to speak about it. And I could have said much more.

The report, "Human Rights Crisis in Puerto Rico: First Amendment Under Siege" is searing.

It details the complaints of students, legislators, the press, and the general public who were beaten and pepper sprayed by police.

Female students who were treated with gross disrespect by the police.

The government's overreaction to demonstrations at the University and at the Capitol over the budget cuts and layoffs...

This is the Capitol building.

This is how the police dealt with protesters.

The images of police tactics and behavior explain why the Department of Justice is investigating the Puerto Rican police for "excessive force" and "unconstitutional searches."

How could you see these images and not speak out?

And I was hardly the first to speak out about these matters and will not be the last...

As a member of Congress, it is more than my right - it is my obligation - to speak out when fundamental freedoms are attacked.

And what was the response to my speech defending the right of the Puerto Rican people to be heard?

It was to challenge my right to be heard.

The resident commissioner of Puerto Rico said that only he is authorized to speak about Puerto Rico in this body.

This week the Puerto Rico legislature debated a resolution of censure - yes, censure -- condemning me for speaking out against these abuses.

A leading member of the ruling party even said, 'Gutierrez was not born in Puerto Rico. His kids weren't born in Puerto Rico. Gutierrez doesn't plan on being buried in Puerto Rico...So Gutierrez doesn't have the right to speak about Puerto Rico...'

Let me tell you something...

If you see injustice anywhere, it is not only your right but your duty to speak out about it.

We don't speak out against injustice, or Apartheid, or human rights abuses, or the denial of rights to women in places around the world because we ourselves were born there.

That's silly.

Where we see injustice we speak out because it is the right thing to do.

Ironically, by questioning my right to speak out on behalf of free speech, they have made my point crystal clear. By challenging my free speech, they have amplified the words of my five minute speech more than if I had spoken for five hours.

And it is their right. My critics have the right of free-speech even as they deny that same right to others.

And I want them to understand this:

Your efforts to silence me - just like your efforts to silence so many people in Puerto Rico who disagree with you -- will fail, just as every effort to blockade progress only makes the march toward justice more powerful and swift.

I may not be Puerto Rican enough for some people, but I know this: nowhere on earth will you find a people harder to silence than Puerto Ricans.

You won't locate my love for Puerto Rico on my birth certificate or a driver's license, my children's birth certificate or any other piece of paper.

My love for Puerto Rico is right here - in my heart -- a heart that beats with our history and our language and our heroes.

A place where -- when I moved there as a teenager -- people talked and argued and debated because we care deeply about our island and our future.

That's still true today - and that freedom is still beating in the hearts of university students, working men and women, labor leaders, lawyers, and environmentalists and every person who believes in free speech.

You will not silence them, and you will not silence me.

Abraham Lincoln, a leader who valued freedom above all else, said:

"Those who deny freedom to others deserve it not for themselves."

It's good advice, and I hope Puerto Rican leaders take it.

Click to add a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

Guest Voz

More in Guest Voz


Guest Voz: Remembering the 43 missing students of Ayotzinapa is to recognize the pursuit of justice in a country wracked with impunity and elitism

Latina ListaSeptember 2, 2015
FILE - In this Feb. 4, 2009 file photo, Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio, left, orders approximately 200 convicted illegal immigrants handcuffed together and moved into a separate area of Tent City, for incarceration until their sentences are served and they are deported to their home countries, in Phoenix.  The Homeland Security Department says it will use 50 immigration agents to screen jail inmates in Arizona’s Maricopa County after it revoked Arpaio's authority to use its systems. Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano revoked that authority on Dec. 15 after a Justice Department investigation concluded that Arpaio's office engaged in a pattern and practice of civil rights and constitutional violations and discriminated against Latino inmates in its jails.   (AP Photo/Ross D. Franklin, File)

Guest Voz: Facts don’t support political rhetoric scapegoating Latino immigrants for crime and lawlessness

Latina ListaAugust 31, 2015

Guest Voz: The High Cost of Truancy

Latina ListaAugust 25, 2015

Guest Voz: The most valuable tool poor people can have to combat effects of climate change

Latina ListaAugust 24, 2015

Guest Voz: From Deported DREAMer to international migration researcher

Latina ListaAugust 10, 2015

Guest Voz: Tech industry’s problem of not including Latinas & others of color goes beyond failing at diversity

Latina ListaAugust 5, 2015

Guest Voz: It will take innovative education to solve the talent dilemma

Latina ListaJuly 30, 2015

Guest Voz: Growing diversity in schools: Challenges and Opportunities

Latina ListaJuly 28, 2015
Photo by Obed Manuel

Guest Voz: Bernie Sanders: the 73-year-old candidate for American millennials

Latina ListaJuly 22, 2015