New report on disparities in student discipline shows there’s no justice for minority and disabled students

New report on disparities in student discipline shows there’s no justice for minority and disabled students

LatinaLista -- "Does a policy of kicking "bad kids" out of school so "good kids" can learn really work?"

That's the premise of a new report released today titled Discipline Policies, Successful Schools, and Racial Justice.

The report, authored by Daniel J. Losen, director of the new Center for Civil Rights Remedies at the Civil Rights Project at UCLA, and one of the nation's top experts on school discipline, documents how a national educational policy of zero tolerance has disproportionately impacted students of color.

These students, who are removed from the classroom and sent to alternative learning environments, are being removed for "relatively minor infractions."

As a result, the students removed from the classroom are suffering academically while there's no evidence that the "good" kids left behind do any better in school without the so-called troublemakers there.

While the report reiterates the findings of earlier reports that found disparities in who gets punished -- young blacks and children with disabilities are receiving the brunt of the punishments -- the bulk of the report is dedicated to focusing on measures implemented in various states that do a better job of keeping kids in the classroom and monitoring disciplinary action.

"Discipline is a core indicator of whether schools are effective," said Losen. "We need good data, collected in a uniform way. It's just plain wrong in an age of data-driven reform to have a scattershot approach to such an important indicator of success or failure. The bottom line is that schools are not proud of the large number of kids being kicked out, so there are no incentives to report these numbers to the public."

According to the report, only 5 percent of all out-of-school suspensions are considered serious or dangerous, like possession of weapons or drugs. The vast majority of suspensions, 95 percent, are for either "disruptive behavior" or "other."

... the high rates of disciplinary removal from school currently seen in American schools cannot reasonably be attributed to the necessary responses to unlawful or dangerous misbehavior. Given the prevalence of less serious offenses, what, then, are the arguments that might justify harsh and frequent removal policies?

It is a report that at the most should serve as the impetus to change how and why students are disciplined in our schools, and at the least, get everyone thinking about it.

Click to add a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply


More in Children


Looks like children’s book publishers need longer time-out to improve diversity in titles

Latina ListaFebruary 26, 2015

Are poor Latino kids the same as their poor white and black peers? Depends on the generation

Latina ListaFebruary 19, 2015

Creators behind Latino children’s summer reading program create special “DIY” reading camp to boost literacy and writing

Latina ListaJune 13, 2014

New study finds low-income Latino parents encourage obesity behaviors in their children beginning in infancy

Latina ListaMarch 17, 2014

Video: Foster care reform includes looking at the facts and acting — not reacting

Latina ListaMarch 11, 2014

Video: Understanding the special needs of siblings of special-needs children

Latina ListaFebruary 4, 2014

Book Review: Young girl learns the value of civic involvement — to a salsa beat

Latina ListaDecember 20, 2013

Viernes Video: Filmmaker creates mini-film about the plight of migrant farmworker children

Latina ListaNovember 8, 2013

Families asked to sign pledge in debut of National Brush Day campaign

Latina ListaNovember 1, 2013