+ ++ Latest accusations against U.S. Border Patrol underscore pervasive problem — refusal to be transparent | Latina Lista
Palabra Final

Latest accusations against U.S. Border Patrol underscore pervasive problem — refusal to be transparent

Latest accusations against U.S. Border Patrol underscore pervasive problem — refusal to be transparent

LatinaLista — On the one hand, the U.S. Border Patrol is being accused by one congressman of practically helping the cause for undocumented immigrants. On the other hand, the agency is being accused by immigrant advocates of violating the most basic human rights when detaining undocumented immigrants.

Both sides can't be right but what could be considered a middle ground is the agency's refusal to be transparent about their policies, procedures and facilities.

Last week, Republican Congressman Darrell Issa accused the U.S. Border Patrol for not counting everybody who got away. The congressman challenged the agency's stand that migrant crossings are down.

In a letter sent to DHS Secretary Janet Napolitano on March 1, Issa says he analyzed a series of Border Patrol shift reports over a one-week period in Casa Grande, Arizona. Those reports showed 82 people who crossed illegally and were never caught, but were also never counted as so-called “got aways.”

The U.S. Border Patrol didn't take kindly to the congressman's accusation.

"The allegation that we’re misrepesenting the data for whatever reason is just patently false at this point,” said Michael Fisher, head of the Border Patrol.

However, other accusations levied against the agency today in Washington at a hearing before the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) won't be so easy to rebuff.

In a hearing titled "Human Rights Situation of Detained and Deported Migrants along the Southern Border of the United States," representatives from eight human rights groups testified highlighting the findings of the humanitarian organization, No More Deaths', 2011 report, "A Culture of Cruelty," about the U.S. Border Patrol's behavior and practices.

Compiling eyewitness testimony over a six-year period and interviewing 15,000 migrants who had been deported, authors of the report told the hearing that the U.S. Border Patrol has a "widespread culture of impunity in which abusive behavior goes unpunished and uncorrected."

Some of the findings of the human rights groups regarding the agency's handling of detained undocumented immigrants entail:

  • 11,384 reports of inadequate access to food;
  • Children were more likely to be denied water than adults;
  • 374 cases of individuals being repatriated without needed emergency medical care or medication;
  • Coercion into signing legal documents;
  • Practices that put vulnerable migrants in harm’s way: dividing families and repatriating vulnerable populations, including children or pregnant women, in the middle of the night;
  • Unsanitary and inhumane processing center conditions;
  • Reports of verbal, physical and psychological abuse.
  • Violations of repatriation agreements between the U.S. and Mexico.
  • Refusal to release complete versions of existing detention policies or to allow civil society organizations access to the facilities to monitor conditions.

The fact that both sides of the immigration issue are accusing the U.S. Border Patrol of not being forthcoming illustrates just how big a problem the agency has. It gives credence to the humanitarian report that the agency acts with a culture of impunity that it doesn't feel it has to answer to anyone.

Unfortunately for this agency, they are not supposed to be operating mini Guantanamos across the country, nor how they treat the detainees is protected from scrutiny. The testimony of the human rights representatives recounted such horrendous behavior — dropping off unaccompanied children and pregnant women in the middle of the night in the most dangerous border towns rife with cartel violence — that it not only calls for an investigation but a thorough housecleaning of such practices and attitudes.

It's no wonder the agency doesn't want to share with anyone how they do business — regardless of which side of the immigration debate is doing the asking.

View Comments (1)
Palabra Final

More in Palabra Final

2_458_fb1ea3e1-53ab-44fa-905f-4574acc211ff

DHS Secretary speaks out about deportation raids as children and parents are rounded up

Latina ListaJanuary 4, 2016
2_442_c91443f3-46fd-4406-a43e-d41af542c14d

Video: How one teacher keeps dreams afloat for the children of migrant farmworkers

Latina ListaDecember 16, 2015
2_437_aa105bd4-019c-4b64-b16f-e47f8ba78fc2

Video: What would the U.S. look like under a Trump directive of mass deportation? Beyond scary!

Latina ListaDecember 11, 2015
2_427_f96a557b-ae7a-4ab9-b962-2ac89cab7710

Commentary: Latino Access to Meaningful Political Representation at Stake in “One Person, One Vote” U.S. Supreme Court Case

Latina ListaDecember 8, 2015
2_373_4af114f2-44f8-4fbe-bbcb-d1bba13f3694

Commentary: Turning our backs on migrant children isn’t solving the immigration issue

Latina ListaNovember 16, 2015
2_324_e463d55e-c8e6-45f1-8c30-1edf20a4d6f0

Bienvenidos to our world, Mainstream Media

Latina ListaOctober 29, 2015
2_296_d6621b19-72a4-419e-9ea7-c40d27751c26 (1)

The Deportation Of Innocence: A Look At America’s Broken Immigration System

Latina ListaOctober 21, 2015
Extended Family Group In Park

New analysis of generational differences hints to a different future for Latinos

Latina ListaOctober 5, 2015
2_204_39a72f73-3fda-4cf8-bdcd-ce8353403838

Video: An American House where the homeless and undocumented find safe refuge

Latina ListaSeptember 17, 2015