In California, Latino and Black Students Are Suspended Disproportionately

In California, Latino and Black Students Are Suspended Disproportionately

By Katherine Leal Unmuth
Latino Ed Beat

A new report by the UCLA Civil Rights Project on the high suspension rates of students in California is generating buzz among legislators and educators alike. The study estimated that more than 400,000 students were removed from class at least once in the 2009-10 school year–”enough to fill every seat in all the professional baseball and football stadiums in the state.”

Of the students in all of the state’s districts, about 7 percent of Latino students, 6 percent of white students, 18 percent of black students, and 3 percent of Asian students had been suspended. The study found that in the 10 districts where suspension rates were highest, nearly one in four students had been suspended. In those 10 districts, suspension rates were 21 percent for Latinos, 21 percent for whites, 41 percent for blacks and 14 percent for Asians. The highest rates for Latino and black males were in the Stockton City United district, where 38 percent of black males and 19 percent of Latino males had been suspended at least once.

Co-author Daniel Losen said many of the removals are for vague infractions such as disrespect, defiance and dress code violations. ”The numbers in our report indicate an absolute crisis in many California districts since suspending students out of school–with no guarantee of adult supervision–greatly increases the risk for dropping out and involvement in the juvenile justice system,” Losen said.

The Sacramento Bee reports that the report that six bills aimed at lowering the suspension rates are being considered by the state’s lawmakers. The study found, for example, that at Roseville Joint Union High School District near Sacramento, 7.1 percent of Latino students had been suspended compared with 3.7 percent of white students.

But in some districts, white students were actually more likely than Latinos to be suspended, although rates among all students were high. The Los Angeles Times pointed out that in the Manteca Unified District south of Stockton 30 percent of Latinos, 33 percent of whites and 60 percent of black students had been suspended. In the Los Angeles Unified district, whites (6 percent) and Latinos (7 percent) were disciplined at somewhat similar rates.

Racial imbalances have been found in other states as well; have you examined the numbers in your state recently? That information should be available by district and even by school. Is your school district using “zero tolerance” policies or are they instituting efforts to address the racial imbalances?

How do teachers feel about the imbalances? I have often found that reports such as this make teachers feel as if they are being accused of being racist, making it tougher to deal with disciplinary issues. What can be done to intervene with the families of these students to change their children’s behavior? Many districts now use behavior interventions and are training teachers on such techniques.

Finally, the study cites a six-year Texas study of middle and high schools that found that suspensions have no academic benefits.

California reporters–or others interested–can find the report, along with more detailed data broken out by district, here.

Click to add a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply


More in BlogBeat


The ‘real’ first Thanksgiving had no turkey or pilgrims but plenty garbanzo beans and Spanish conquistadores

Latina ListaNovember 24, 2015

New Model Helps Better Predict Breast Cancer in Latinas

Latina ListaNovember 23, 2015

UN Special Rapporteur Exposes Indigenous Rights Violations During Official Country Visit to Honduras

Latina ListaNovember 19, 2015

Are Texas textbooks making cops more trigger-happy?

Latina ListaNovember 18, 2015

States Look Beyond Incarceration to Rearrest Rates

Latina ListaNovember 17, 2015

Recent Stories Highlight Latino Student Segregation Problem

Latina ListaNovember 16, 2015

Hidden bias says women don’t look like leaders

Latina ListaNovember 10, 2015

How the science of human behavior is beginning to reshape the US government

Latina ListaNovember 9, 2015

Documentary Aims Spotlight on Broken Juvenile Justice System

Latina ListaNovember 5, 2015