+ ++ Study: Where We’ll Sympathize With an Individual, We Throw the Book at a Group | Latina Lista
BlogBeat

Study: Where We’ll Sympathize With an Individual, We Throw the Book at a Group

Study: Where We’ll Sympathize With an Individual, We Throw the Book at a Group

By David Berreby
This View of Life

For some time now, cognitive scientists have been sure that the mind is not made for logical reasoning. That ability is just a lucky side effect of the work brains actually evolved to do.

For example, people can learn, with some difficulty, to solve a logic problem with abstract symbols. But it's much easier when turned into a question about who the bartender has to card tonight. Similarly, a purely logical mind would look at a collection of human beings — say, the citizens of Iran — and see an agglomeration of individuals, very few of whom have any say over whether their government develops nuclear weapons.

But the human mind is tuned for signs of people operating together as a team. So we say things like "Iran is trying to obtain nuclear weapons" or "Iran deserves to be annihilated." In fact, according to this paper, the more we see people as part of a coherent group, the more harshly we judge their actions.

This is not exactly a secret to propagandists and other political types, who know that bombing Iran is a respectable subject for high-minded policy types, while possibly bombing Asghar Farhadi and his family just sounds like a Mafia hit.

Yet, as people who actually have to drop bombs have said, those are two different descriptions of the same decision, so psychologists should be able to explain why our reaction depends on our description of the choice. That's what the new paper, which went online last month before print publication in a future issue of The Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, is about.

Its roots are in a powerful idea worked out in the middle of the last century by the philosopher and social scientist Donald T. Campbell. He proposed that the mind, when faced with any collection of people, can end up treating that group as if it were a coherent, single object that takes up a particular space and persists through time — in other words, as later work found, as if it were a single being, with thoughts, feelings, and intentions.

What determined this perception, Campbell thought, were certain specific cues: For instance, if people are all dressed alike (as soldiers are), if they're close together (think soldiers again), or if it's obvious that they share the same fate (think sailors, all in the same boat), then the mind is more inclined to perceive them as a single entity than as a collection of different Bobs and Daves and Barbs and Donnas.

(The actual traits of the group aren't particularly relevant, because any assemblage of people — China, Tea Partiers, Catholics, Red Sox fans — can be made to look either like a monotone forest or like a varied stand of individual trees.

It's all about how the people are perceived, which is what this paper examines.)

Read more at Big Think

Click to add a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

BlogBeat

More in BlogBeat

2_461_12928a81-6ed5-4e3c-be23-8dfe50af78e3

More Mexicans are leaving the US than coming across the border

Latina ListaJanuary 5, 2016
2_454_03bc190f-3ad8-4aec-8e45-f6d77114e7ad

Black, Latino Boys in Boston Want Better Schools

Latina ListaDecember 21, 2015
2_450_3c520db6-5dc2-4698-bd58-df175083955a

Maps track spread of U.S. social movements

Latina ListaDecember 17, 2015
2_446_4f6e28c8-08c7-4bff-a70e-497c0aca2963

The Woman Who Made Sure We Remembered The Alamo

Latina ListaDecember 16, 2015
2_440_2f5403e1-c75f-4690-b300-d0a2045cb28b

Sports history shows why playing ball with Cuba makes sense

Latina ListaDecember 15, 2015
2_435_44064724-1dc6-428e-88af-d1bd1c395b8c

Helping Latina children’s book author nationally shine with the #DRUMITUP campaign

Latina ListaDecember 10, 2015
2_430_76f4e942-2f50-4ca1-9aa1-4f2999224188

Do custom news feeds give us rigid views?

Latina ListaDecember 9, 2015
2_426_c0fc302c-7074-4bca-bbc2-c56bcbd9c171

Research: Latino Families Have Worse Access to Healthy Food

Latina ListaDecember 8, 2015
2_420_e9e0bd4d-b4d9-42bf-9e81-ef5b65957c7c

FAFSA Application: Everything You Need to Know in 2016

Latina ListaDecember 7, 2015