Palabra Final

Conservative pundit says immigrants’ rights are not Civil Rights. Who is she kidding?

Conservative pundit says immigrants’ rights are not Civil Rights. Who is she kidding?

LatinaLista — No Sunday TV viewing is complete without watching the Sunday morning pundit roundtables. It was a nice surprise to see Jorge Ramos as one of this week with George Stephanopoulos' panelists. Of course, it was to recognize the new ABC/Univision partnership and Ramos' recent interviews with Romney and Obama, but it was nice to have someone there who was speaking from firsthand knowledge rather than making assumptions.

It just so happened that another guest on the show was Ann Coulter. An extreme conservative who can have an acid tongue, Coulter was holding back from her usual demeanor of being totally disagreeable. She probably thought the more she smiled and wasn't too combative people would buy her new book, which she shamelessly hawked.

Yet anyone with as many strong opinions as Coulter can't keep quiet for too long, book to sell or not, and that's what happened to Coulter. In her book, which I have not read, she makes a statement that Stephanopoulos referred to where Coulter says that immigrant rights are not civil rights.

Coulter, author of the new book “Mugged: Racial Demagoguery From the Seventies to Obama,” also argued that groups on the left, from feminists to gay rights groups to those defending immigrants, have commandeered the black civil rights experience.

“I think what — the way liberals have treated blacks like children and many of their policies have been harmful to blacks, at least they got the beneficiary group right,” Coulter said. “There is the legacy of slavery and Jim Crow laws. We don’t owe the homeless. We don’t owe feminists. We don’t owe women who are desirous of having abortions, but that’s — or — or gays who want to get married to one another. That’s what civil rights has become for much of the left.”

When asked whether immigrant rights were not civil rights, Coulter responded, “No. I think civil rights are for blacks… What have we done to the immigrants? We owe black people something. We have a legacy of slavery. Immigrants haven’t even been in this country.”

Coulter goes on to say that Democrats are now dropping Blacks and moving on to Hispanics because there's more Hispanics.

Listening to her rationale, I was struck at how differently I see the issue of civil rights.

For me, civil rights doesn't belong to one demographic. It may be more closely identified with African Americans but only because the injustices were so brutal, blatant and have lasted so long. But civil rights belongs to anyone living in the United States who suffers the injustices that are characterized as civil rights violations.

The idea that it can only be the domain of one group doesn't make sense, especially as that group matures politically, professionally and socially. What will happen to that day when African Americans reach that stage where they no longer have to worry about discrimination, racial profiling, etc. (Hopefully, that day will arrive)

Is this to say civil rights dies? Yet, history shows that when one ethnic group matures and achieves equal assimilation, another group takes its place.

Coulter's argument underscores how she views the reality that exists in this nation — through a very narrow lens, which has always made it easier to make up your own stories about how history should be written.

View Comments (2)


  1. Anacleto Castillo

    September 24, 2012 at 5:28 pm

    Can I write an opposing op ed? I was apalled by her.

  2. Amuro

    September 25, 2012 at 11:07 am

    But she is right about immigrant rights not being civil rights. No matter how people try and it up illegal immigrants do not have the right to reside within the U.S. No it is not an unjust law either or even a racist law half of our legal immigrants come from Mexico and we also get a lot from other Latin American countries. So she is right in saying that people pushing for legalization of illegal immigrants are wrong when they try and brand it as civil rights. Because it’s not even close or even remotely the same thing as denying American citizens rights that our endowed by our creator. It doesn’t matter if someone lives in the US illegally or there here on visa and over stay.
             When they entered they came on a visa with certain terms and they are supposed to abide by those terms and if they don’t they have to leave. Now if someone entered illegally then they never even had a right to be here and should leave immediately. I’m not sure people understand how offensive it is to compare people getting deported who have no right to be here to people getting lynched, raped, and bombed for trying to exercise their right to free speech and vote. The only thing worse than that is comparing helping someone commit identity theft to the “Underground Rail Road”. Also being deported is not a civil rights violation neither is being asked for identification when you get pulled over during a traffic stop. 

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

Palabra Final

More in Palabra Final


Video: An American House where the homeless and undocumented find safe refuge

Latina ListaSeptember 17, 2015

Brewing Hatred: Coors Beer Company Markets to Women, Latinos, LGBTQ Communities as Coors Family Attacks Their Rights

Latina ListaSeptember 16, 2015
Photo by Obed Manuel

“Dump the Trump” rally sounds off against Trump and his supporters

Latina ListaSeptember 15, 2015

Guest Voz: Donald Trump is at it again. This time he messed with the wrong person.

Latina ListaAugust 26, 2015

This undocumented immigrant works in a Trump hotel. Here’s what he had to say.

Latina ListaAugust 18, 2015

Immigration lawyer, tireless fighter for the undocumented, now finds himself at mercy of the court — because he exposed an unlawful truth

Latina ListaAugust 12, 2015

‘Visions From The Inside’ Taps 15 Artists To Illustrate The Letters Of Detained Migrants

Latina ListaAugust 5, 2015
Voting booths at Hermosa Beach City Hall during California Primary

New Census report shows critical segment of Latino population not voting

Latina ListaJuly 16, 2015

Report analyzing “Health of State Democracies” finds majority of Latinos live in high-ranking states

Latina ListaJuly 8, 2015