Environment

House committee OKs bill to waive environmental rules for Border Patrol

House committee OKs bill to waive environmental rules for Border Patrol

By Joshua Armstrong
Cronkite News Service

WASHINGTON - A House committee approved a bill Wednesday that would waive environmental regulations for Border Patrol activities within 100 miles of any U.S. border.

Rep. Rob Bishop, R-Utah, has said his National Security and Federal Lands Protection Act clears up the Border Patrol's "checkerboard access," but environmental groups charge the bill does little to affect border security while risking protected lands and species.

The House Natural Resources Committee passed the bill, 26-17.

The measure would allow border agents to build fences, construct roads, set up monitoring equipment and patrol with vehicles on reservations and federal wildlands. It would apply to only the land borders with Canada and Mexico.

The Pew Environment Group said that means the Border Patrol would have waivers in places like Long Island and Northern California - far from the Southwest deserts typically associated with immigration and trafficking problems.

"It's horrible; it's unbelievable," said Dan Millis, borderlands campaign organizer for the Sierra Club's Grand Canyon chapter. "Those of us who live on the southern border have seen what these waivers have done, the environmental damage that occurs."

Areas along the U.S.-Mexico border are already exempt from many environmental protections under similar waivers. Millis said walls and infrastructure built under those provisions have caused flooding and eroded ranch land.

But the environmental impact of smugglers and people who cross the border illegally is worse than anything the Border Patrol might do, said Patrick Bray, executive vice president of the Arizona Cattle Growers' Association. He said border-crossers leave behind large amounts of trash, including numerous bicycles and, in some cases, automobiles.

"The damages created by (illegal border-crossers) are far more than what the Border Patrol could do," he said.

Bray said dealing with the land-management agencies still causes plenty of snags for agents, and that brings the Border Patrol agents to ask private landowners to help them instead.

"It puts it upon the private citizens," he said.

But critics charge that border security is not the true purpose of the bill. Rep. Raul Grijalva, D-Tucson, called it a Trojan-horse tactic to attack environmental protections, and that using immigration issues as cover is "a smart political ploy that could be detrimental to the American people."

"The intent is to set the precedent that these laws can be waived, they can be suspended - inevitably leading to the removal of most of those laws," he said.

He noted that the bill is opposed by Customs and Border Protection. The agency, part of the Department of Homeland Security, already has effective working relationships with the Department of the Interior and the Department of Agriculture, it said in a written statement in June, when the bill was up for a hearing.

Grijalva does not expect the bill to move far, certainly not past the Democrat-controlled Senate, nor to be signed into law by President Barack Obama.

"Still," he said, "we have to fight it."

Click to add a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

Environment

More in Environment

b052db29569fe7a298db13bf1a0a7d799750f438_preview.jpg

VIDEO: With climate change worsening, hope is but a tree away

Latina ListaJuly 28, 2014
Fishing_Nevada-1200x500

Video: New poll underscores tie between the environment and Latino communities

Latina ListaJune 16, 2014
Monarchbutterfly2

Deepening crisis in Monarch butterfly population has one researcher calling on states to help in special way

Latina ListaMarch 20, 2014
Untitled

Keeping the familia safe while ridding cucarachas & weeds calls for better choices in household chemicals

Latina ListaMarch 5, 2014
ShaftsofLight_HuffPost

Video: Time-lapse filmmaker unlocks key to a beauty that inspires gratitude

Latina ListaFebruary 25, 2014
EPA-Carbon

New environmental poll reveals Latinos care as intensely about the issue as immigration reform

Latina ListaJanuary 23, 2014
436791239_640

Intern’l Video: The páramos of Colombia highlight the fragile future of the planet’s supply of fresh water

Latina ListaJanuary 8, 2014
changing_oil

Video: A fun lesson on recycling motor oil underscores a serious threat to clean drinking water

Latina ListaDecember 10, 2013
waterconservation

Video: Climate Action superhero teaches all ages how one simple act can conserve tons of water

Latina ListaDecember 3, 2013