Palabra Final

Trayvon Martin’s death underscores how race is used for both reason and reaction

Trayvon Martin’s death underscores how race is used for both reason and reaction

LatinaLista — Sunday morning, I heard something somewhat profound that caused me to do a mental double-take. I wasn't sitting in a church pew but rather in my own home watching the Sunday morning news talk shows. Every show that morning, to be expected, was talking about the killing of 17-year-old Trayvon Martin.

On "Meet the Press," moderator, David Gregory, asked one of the panelists, Michelle Norris, about how much attitude and suspicion played a part in the killing. Her response was eye-opening, not original, but something that has to be repeated time and time again to finally sink in. She replied that she didn't know if race had anything to do with the killing and that law enforcement will determine if race was a factor, but that race was a part of the reaction to it.

The first reports, based on the 911 call, seemed to show that George Zimmerman was a police officer wannabe who was too eager to play cop that day and pursued Trayvon, who was visiting his father's girlfriend who lived in the gated community. From those initial recordings, Zimmerman's claim of self-defense sounded absurd and the police's refusal to arrest him, law or no law, obscene.

It was enough of a reflection of the kind of travesty in justice that has historically plagued communities of color that outrage wasn't just rightful but necessary in this day and in these times.

Now, new details about that face-off are emerging that cast a significant doubt on the way the nation thinks it went down.

Will it make a difference to the outrage and the anguish sweeping across the country?

Probably not. This case has stirred emotions that have always existed but were buried so deeply that it took a perceived outrage to galvanize national unity on an issue that should have been on the frontburner of the national dialogue long ago — how we see, hear and live with each other. In other words, race relations.

A country whose whole foundation for being is based on immigration, representing thousands of countries and cultures on one continent, and yet we live with this prevailing notion, however subconscious, that you don't belong unless you're white.

In a recent column by Leonard Pitts titled ‘White’ isn’t color, it’s privilege, he writes:

The people who came here from Europe did not automatically consider themselves “white.” They identified as Irish, Hungarian, Italian, Jewish, Armenian.

As David R. Roediger observes in his book, “Working Toward Whiteness: How America’s Immigrants Became White,” they were emphatically taught that “white” was the identity that conferred status and privilege and that it was defined by distance from, and antipathy toward, black.

Nor did Africans kidnapped into slavery think of themselves as “black.” They were Mandinkan, Fulani, Mende, Songhay, Wolof. “Black” was something imposed upon them as justification for slavery and other means of exploitation. As one historian puts it: Africans did not become slaves because they were black. They became black because they were enslaved.

Well into the 20th century, America recognized dozens of “races.” In that America, people we now regard as white — the Irishman, Conan O’Brien; the Armenian, Andre Agassi; the Jew, Jerry Seinfeld — could not have taken for granted that they would be seen that way. People like this had to become white, had to earn whiteness, a feat African-Americans have found impossible to duplicate, no matter how many harsh chemicals they use on their hair and skin.

White, then, is not simply color, but privilege — not necessarily in the sense of wealth, but rather in the sense of having one’s personhood and individuality respected, a privilege so basic I doubt it registers with many whites as privilege at all. We’re talking about the privilege of being seen, of having your worth presumed, of receiving the benefit of the doubt.

The sad confrontation that resulted in a needless loss of life that day in Sanford, Florida happens every day, with loss of life measured in different ways, when ignorant politicians talk about making English the official language or educators assume some Latino or African American children aren't "teachable," or mainstream media prefers to use, over the objections of fellow journalists, the adjective "illegal" to modify a person or when legislators would deny students brought to this country as young children the opportunity to attend college because they have no citizenship or …the list goes on.

The likelihood of another Trayvon Martin - Zimmerman confrontation is highly probable unless the national dialogue seriously starts to include addressing a topic that is long overdue and has a shorter and shorter fuse.

View Comments (1)

1 Comment

  1. Pingback: Zimmerman Case Ignites Dialogue on Latino Racial Identity | The Hartford Guardian

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

Palabra Final

More in Palabra Final


Commentary: Turning our backs on migrant children isn’t solving the immigration issue

Latina ListaNovember 16, 2015

Bienvenidos to our world, Mainstream Media

Latina ListaOctober 29, 2015
2_296_d6621b19-72a4-419e-9ea7-c40d27751c26 (1)

The Deportation Of Innocence: A Look At America’s Broken Immigration System

Latina ListaOctober 21, 2015
Extended Family Group In Park

New analysis of generational differences hints to a different future for Latinos

Latina ListaOctober 5, 2015

Video: An American House where the homeless and undocumented find safe refuge

Latina ListaSeptember 17, 2015

Brewing Hatred: Coors Beer Company Markets to Women, Latinos, LGBTQ Communities as Coors Family Attacks Their Rights

Latina ListaSeptember 16, 2015
Photo by Obed Manuel

“Dump the Trump” rally sounds off against Trump and his supporters

Latina ListaSeptember 15, 2015

Guest Voz: Donald Trump is at it again. This time he messed with the wrong person.

Latina ListaAugust 26, 2015

This undocumented immigrant works in a Trump hotel. Here’s what he had to say.

Latina ListaAugust 18, 2015